Eating my Curds and Ditching the Whey – Homemade Ricotta Cheese

Last Friday, I was babysitting my amazing and adorable 10-month old nephew.  I love this kid like crazy, so I look forward to being able spend time with him, especially since I have all the time in the world at this juncture!  Naturally, the best part of being with him is cuddling him, playing with him, and hell, the diaper changes are no big whoop at all because nothing ‘baby Zach’ is gross to me.  One game he really loves I call ‘Bouncy Bouncy Boo Boo’.  I lie on my back and lift him up and down – bringing him all the way to my face so we touch noses, then all the way back up so he can ‘fly’.

While we do this, I repeat “BOUNCY BOUNCY BOO BOO” sporadically, in a silly voice, which makes him laugh hysterically.  His sweet and goofy laughter just fills my heart and makes it impossible not to smile so wide that my cheeks hurt.  Well, he got into such a fit of laughter during Bouncy Bouncy Boo Boo last Friday, that when I brought him back down to touch noses, my gaping grin so wide that you could probably see my wisdom teeth from a mile away, he suddenly dropped his head full force – right onto my right front tooth – PAIN plus a CRACKY like noise, then numbness.  It felt like an anvil had crashed through my roof and onto that tooth.

3168_70646684204_588779204_1684626_6286219_n                                               My sis and baby boulder head

Of course, my first concern was him, but he was fine, still laughing – the babe has one hard head!  After checking his head, looking into his eyes, and panicking briefly, I afforded myself a nano-second to examine my tooth.  A little blood, and boy did it hurt, but of most concern, after him, was the fact that it felt a little loose.  OH NO!  *stereotype alert* Is it time to pack me off to Appalachia with a case of pork rinds and a banjo?? Should I take up ice hockey? (This, and stereotype #2 below, is not meant to hurt or insult anyone.  I’m referring to the movie, ‘Deliverance’, not the actual, beautiful and ‘toothy’ people who live in Appalachia.  Never, ever saw a person with a missing tooth when I was there!).


Just my luck, my dentist wasn’t going to be back in the office until Wednesday for evening hours, but I was told that if it’s only slight mobility, the tooth will tighten up on its own within a few days to a week – just stay away from hard foods like apples, hard pretzels etc.  Well, it has tightened up a little, and the pain has subsided, but it still feels weird, so I’m setting up an appointment for Tuesday or Wednesday, just to be safe.



Because of this, I’ve been existing on soup for the past week. I don’t want to take ANY chance of a chunk of even soft fruit in yogurt jostling that tooth. What a perfect time to try homemade ricotta cheese!  It’s soft, no biting gaping hole smile.

Technically, this isn’t how ricotta cheese is made, but it tastes exactly like (but better) the ricotta cheese we’re all used to and it IS ricotta cheese. Ricotta (meaning recooked) is usually made out of whey, the liquid separated out from the curds when cheese is made, like mozzarella, and recooked.  In this recipe, you’re using the whole milk plus acid to make the ricotta and discarding the whey (although you can use it in homemade breads, or other preparations which I can’t conjure up at this moment).  This is the perfect time to ask, Can anyone think of any good uses for the liquid whey outside of watering the garden?  I have this weird obsession with waste.

Not only is this easy with just 4 ingredients and a super rapid cooking time, but the results are well worth it.  You’ll never want to eat store bought again, although it does take quite a bit of milk – as in 8 cups of milk plus 1 cup of cream for a yield of about 1 1/2 to 2 cups ricotta,  OK, maybe you shouldn’t completely rule out store bought, but trust me – this is well worth tackling every so often, and the fresh, creamy result is to die for.

By the way, it didn’t jostle my tooth, so I may not have to relocate after all.  This is a good thing *stereotype alert #2* as demanding that someone bend over and “squeal like a pig!!” is not something I ever aspired to do, not even in a kinky way.

IMG_0338_edited                                      MY ‘soft’ dinner – with honey and black pepper

Finally, there is another reason I made this, but you’ll have to stay tuned to find out *don’t you hate when people do that?*  I know I’ve said this before and not come through (I accidentally deleted the photos of what I did with the all dark chocolate Valentino *I paired it with spiced, Frangelico poached pears, hazelnuts and creme fraiche*- and the supposedly soon coming post on the A-Rod deal), but this time it’s for real – I SUHwear.


Homemade Ricotta Cheese
Prep time: 
Cook time: 
Total time: 
Yield: 1½ to 2 cups fresh ricotta
Straining time: 1 to 2 hours
Recipe from Brooklyn Farmhouse
  • 8 cups whole milk
  • 1 cup heavy cream
  • 1 teaspoon kosher or sea salt (more or less to taste)
  • 3 tablespoons fresh lemon juice
  1. Line a large strainer or sieve with cheesecloth * and place the strainer over a large bowl.
  2. In a large pot or saucepan, bring the milk, cream, and salt to a boil over medium heat, stirring occasionally to keep milk mixture from scorching.
  3. Add all the lemon juice, reduce heat to low and simmer, stirring gently once or twice, for 2 minutes. The mixture will curdle immediately.
  4. Pour the mixture into the cheesecloth lined strainer and let drain for an hour or two. Discard the liquid whey (Can be used in bread baking!) and refrigerate the ricotta or use immediately. If you want it really dry, wrap it back up with the cheesecloth, leave it in the strainer over the bowl, weight it down with something heavy, and refrigerate overnight.
* If you can't find cheesecloth, paper coffee filters work well.

Homemade Ricotta Cheese - 4 Ingredients, 2 minutes cooking time. SO much better than store bought! Outside of the typical uses, try it with honey and black pepper! Bookmark and Share

This entry was posted in Amuse Bouche, Appetizers, Cheese, Dinner, Gluten Free, Lunch and tagged , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

76 Responses to Eating my Curds and Ditching the Whey – Homemade Ricotta Cheese

  1. Elyse says:

    Oh my goodness. Zach is totally precious, and man, that kid must have one hard noggin. Glad to hear your tooth is feeling better and that you’ll be able to see the dentist soon enough. Man oh man, what an accident! In the mean time, this “soft” ricotta looks amazing! I really need to try my hand at making it!

  2. slow-1 says:

    Does it still taste grainy like most store bought Ricotta?

  3. Beautiful pixs of the ricotta and the baby. Things happen for a reason sometimes and this time it was for you to make this tooth friendly soft ricotta. Your cheese shots are most professional. Waiting for your surprize.

  4. lisamichele says:

    slow-1 – Actually, it did not have a grainy taste or texture at all – ‘curdy’….but creamier than store bought. I think that probably has something to do with the heavy cream.

    Thanks Audax and Elyse! :)

  5. Maris says:

    OMG Lisa what an adorable little guy! That big smile is precious.

  6. Laura says:

    Oh lord I’ve been bonked by my kids like that… and it hurts. Usually my nose or chin–I’ve never gotten a loose tooth. Although I know someone whose cornea was scratched by her kid–yikes.

    I’ve never liked ricotta–but reading this I gotta wonder if homemade would change my mind.

  7. Denise says:

    Hey pretty girl, your blog is looking fierce! I’m blown away that you made ricotta cheese from scratch! If I stop over, could you whip up a batch for me? I’ll just eat it out of the strainer with a spoon!

  8. ingrid says:

    Your nephew is crazy cute! You know that their heads are so hard and soft (insane right?) at the same time to keep THEM from getting hurt. On of the twins fell so much I worried about brain damamge. The doctors told me if I was that concerned to put a helmet on him and let him go otherwise except for something extreme he’d be fine. You know except when he’s playing sports he’s an accident waiting to happen.

    I love ricotta cheese and you’re saying this is even better? Hmmmm, I’ll be honest I’mnot sure about the honey and black pepper together on top of my ricotta cheese. I’ll have to take your word it’s a just do it!

    Btw, are you finally pushing 100%? Or do you still have a ways to go?

  9. tiamatsrevenge says:

    OMK!! That’s what I don’t have for my lasagna … LOL

    I found my card reader and uploaded my cookie pix …

    Your pix make mine look horrible … You’d never know that I got a degree in photo-journalism … But, then again, there’s a difference between “still life” and “real life” … LOL

  10. There’s nothing like homemade ricotta!

  11. Juliana says:

    Interesting recipe…I’d like to try it. The baby is very precious. Great pictures.

  12. John says:

    Great ricotta cheese..gonna roll that up in some manicotti?

    Oh, heard what happened….is he crazy? I’m here if you need a shoulder, or anything…….. seriously.

  13. I love that you’ve made your own ricotta! Cheese making is one of those things I’ve never tried but yours looks so delicious, I really should!

  14. Mirthful says:

    Aha. Now that’s an idea. Home-made ricotta would fit the bill perfectly.

  15. Tooth…OH NO! Baby Boulder Head…HA!

    Honey on ricotta does rock — I went to a honey tasting that paired them together and I was in hog heaven (that’s a shout out to your stereotype inserts…which made me literally LOL). The instructor mentioned how easy it would be to make your own ricotta…and looks like you’ve proved him right! Do you think…it could be done with 2%?? I wonder if it would achieve the same effect (albeit not as delicious, I’m sure!).

    And…um…Yankees? Very depressing. So depressing I may just need to splurge and go for the whole milk. 😉

  16. Katrina says:

    Ooh, ouch! I hope your tooth is feeling better by now!
    Cool, ricotta!

  17. Sophie says:

    Home made ricotta is lovely & delicious! You did a great & wonderful job! Honey goes great with ricotta!

  18. Rosa says:

    Fantastic! I’ll also have to try making my own fresh cheese soon…



  19. Giselle says:


    I sent you an email and tried to call, but no answer either way. So so sorry for your loss, honey. I’m here for you..always.

  20. BitterSweet says:

    Aww, such an adorable little nephew you have Hopefully you can help teach him to be a real foodie as he grows up. 😉

  21. A&N says:

    Ricotta is on our to-do list for the daring cooks this weekend 😉
    and is there a reason you chose to add pepper? Thats a really interesting combination (honey and black pepper).

    and I think I’ll spare too many comments about the Yankees. I am surprised that there is no website titled ‘’ or ‘’

  22. Arlette says:

    I hope you are doing with your tooth!!!!
    nice looking Ricotta and delicious flavours.
    I love the home made Ricotta,or as we say in Arabic fresh Areesheh.
    one of the best selling sandwiches in Lebanon, specially if you are going on a tour trip the bus driver will stop at one place in Shtourah – Bekaa, and every one will go for a sandwich of warm fresh Lavash Bread and Areesheh w Assal(Ricotta with Honey)
    the owners of that place has their own dairy farm.

    thanks for sharing the recipe

  23. Sarah says:

    I recently made fresh ricotta and used the whey as a cooking liquid for pasta.

    Maybe kind of indulgent, but definitely delicious.

  24. Snuggle Puppy says:

    Hi Lisa,
    Sorry Zach gets a little too excited playing with you. He whacked me in the eyebrow with a remote control a few weeks ago. Looks like I might need a helmet being his Mom. Your ricotta looks amazing! Can’t wait to try it. Hope you are feeling better. We’ll get through this.


  25. shellyfish says:

    Ha ha ha! Can’t wait to see the “why”! :)
    I hope your tooth is ok – but what a freaking cutie! Hannah at Bittersweet had a bread recipe using whey – it was soy but it would probably work ok for you.

  26. susie says:

    left my comment on your about your photos and I will be back! Thanks for dropping by!

  27. Mark says:

    Lisa, a little birdie told me what happened. Double whammy is an understatement and I wish i could say something soothing outside of a cliche “I’m so sorry, sweetie”. You are beautiful, and pure sunshine, especially when you flash that dazzling smile. You always made everyone around you feel great, and that’s a gift. Rotten luck downed you for a while, but that inner glow was still there waiting to bust out in full force again.

    Alright, I’m starting to sound like a bad poet, so since this is your blog, and this blog is about your STOMACH GROWLING cuisine, I need to demand that once you’ve healed, you’re making me dinner and dessert! Now, will you check your work email addy, please?? I bet it’s filled to the brim. Lots of love, M

  28. Alana says:

    I got inspired by your post and got to making my ricotta today, and oddly enough, the milk didn’t curdle when I added the lemon! I did some quick research and added white vinegar, and it did the trick. Your ricotta looks luscious though- and thanks for the inspiration.

  29. Jose says:

    The beautiful pearl was callously ejected out of the shell she loved and lived in for years….BUT this is a good thing! Now we gotta get you walkin’ again, babe!

    Oh, I want your cheese..and your cheesecake too 😉

  30. Barbara says:

    I remember getting whacked by my kids and it hurts! Your ricotta looks perfect. I’ll look forward to your secret post!

  31. pinkstripes says:

    Your nephew is so cute!! Your homemade ricotta looks gorgeous. I really need to make my own one day.

  32. Jude says:

    Glad to hear you didn’t have to lose it. If it means I’d be having something like this, I wouldn’t mind the momentary pain.

  33. Natalie says:

    Hope your tooth is ok!!
    Your homemade ricotta looks so delicious and creamy!

  34. Alana says:

    I made English Muffin bread with my whey. It was a success I think, and I avoided pouring it down the drain.

  35. Elle says:

    That is one cute baby…with, thank heavens, a hard head. Glad your tooth is OK. The ricotta looks amazing, but sounds like quite a process. Didn’t know you could water the garden with whey…will have to try that when I make fresh ricotta!

  36. Sophie says:

    MMMMMM….home made ricotta! Looks so lovely & yummie!!!

  37. msmeanie says:

    I love homemade ricotta. It’s also called paneer (Indian cheese). There are some great Indian recipes that use paneer. Thanks for visiting my blog! Your site is great. I will be back for more recipes!

  38. Pingback: This is the first Daring Cooks Challenge – Ricotta Gnocchi « Parsley, Sage, Desserts and Line Drives

  39. I’ve been hit it the nose by my infant son with a hard plastic teething ring, and heard a loud crack. Luckily, it was just bruised. Hope your tooth feels better. Honey and cheese is one of my favorite pairings…

    I just read a Slate article about how you can save the whey to use instead of water when you make bread or bagels. Here’s the link:

  40. Catalina says:

    This looks so yummy!
    You can use the whey to lacto-ferment lots of things.
    Like pickles, black beans, ect.
    It’s very easy.

  41. Pingback: Finger Bun, Black Olive & Chocolate and Rice Pudding Cannoli recipe, Daring Bakers November 2009 challenge @Not Quite Nigella

  42. Pingback: “Leave the Gun, Take the Cannoli” « Parsley, Sage, Desserts and Line Drives

  43. Pingback: Daring Bakers November Challenge: Cannoli « Sticks and Scones

  44. Pingback: Daring Bakers November 2009|Cannoli | Bake Like A Ninja

  45. Thanks so much for the impetus to finally make ricotta. I’ve really enjoyed getting to know you through the Secret Recipe Club.

  46. well written article, saved this page, I’ll be returning later.

  47. Pingback: Delphia

  48. jamieflares says:

    This is basically how you make paneer for Indian dishes! The recipe I have for paneer doesn’t use the salt, but is otherwise the same as the “extra dry” version of this where your press more water out. Mmm…love me some saag paneer w/ some fresh homemade paneer!

    • Lisa says:

      Yep…I’ve made paneer too..the only difference being that paneer is technically..a little extra salt and pressing would also give you ricotta salata :)

  49. Food Snob says:

    Use the whey for fermented veggies. Check out the cookbook Nourishing Traditions by Sally Fallon. The sauerkraut is wonderful!!!!

  50. Yummy! Have done this before, but not the honey and pepper pairing. Interesting! Use the whey in smoothies, if you want the protein. 😉

    • Lisa says:

      Thanks for the tip on using the whey, Rosemarie, can’t wait to try it! Try the honey and pepper, it’s a great dessert or snack! :)

  51. Brittany says:

    Use whey to make probiotic lemonade!

  52. laura N says:

    You can find a rricotta at Aldi’s…Priano brand. Not grainy at all. I want to try this recipe, though.

  53. beth says:

    Whey~lacto fermented foods!!!!! pickling without boiling vinegar! the natural way. very nutritious and super tasty! probiotics from food you made!

    • Lisa says:

      You.are.awesome. Thank you so much for that, Beth! I never, ever would have even entertained the idea and now I’m wicked excited to try it!! Time to make some more cheese to get to the whey! lol

  54. Marti says:

    So this would be luscious for lasagna????? Looks delish!

    • Lisa says:

      Ack, some of my comments got lost! Just ran into yours! So sorry for the delay! That said, absolutely luscious for lasagna! I’m guessing about double the recipe for the ricotta would fill a lasagna well :)

  55. aj says:

    This cheese can be used to make cheese cake. It is just as tasty and more economical than store bought. I like your photo shots too.

    • Lisa says:

      Yes, aj! Ricotta cheesecake is amazing! Or cut in ricotta with cream cheese or mascarpone! :) Thank you for the photo compliments! I love the pouring shots!

  56. MochasMom says:

    Wow. I pinned this for the ricotta recipe. When I actually went through and read the post, I was appalled. I’m from the heart of Appalachia, and your stereotype jokes were in very poor taste. It isn’t socially acceptable to make fun of people for being from any other part of the world, why should Appalachia be any different? Can you imagine the outcry if your stupid stereotype jokes pertained to “the ghetto” or “some third-world country”?

    • Lisa says:

      Wow, I’m really sorry you were offended by that, MochasMom. I made a point to say ‘stereotype alert’ meaning it’s a joke and not meant to insult or hurt anyone. In fact, I’ve spent a lot of time in the Appalachian area and the people are lovely and wonderful – never saw any missing teeth. 😉 I was making fun of myself and using the fictional hillbilly ‘Deliverance’ movie angle was my way to get that across in a joking, satirical way. It certainly was never my intention to be disrespectful or demeaning to anyone in any way. I added a side note to the post clear that up.

  57. Ahmed Laboy says:

    Me gusto esas recetas pero del queso ricotta super

  58. martha says:

    mmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm estoy segura me encantara y facilicimoooooooo me encanta gracias

  59. Wendy says:

    I just took a cheese cooking class and they said whey is a secret ingredient for breads

  60. baketrail says:

    I wonder, will this work with UHT milk or does it have to be fresh?

    • Lisa says:

      Hi there! I’ve never tried this with anything but fresh milk, so I can’t confirm that it will work, but it’s definitely worth a try! Some of our best inventions were the result of trying things that may or may not work :)

  61. Cheryl Lane says:

    If you like ginger ale, it is made with whey. Can’t remember the other ingredients at this time. I do know that it takes real ginger. I think some lemon juice, I know there was something to sweeten it. Anyway, you leave it sit in a canning jar for about 3 days and it is done. It is easy to make. You can strain it so you won’t have bits of lemon pulp or ginger floating around in the drink. I pinned this just the other day so I will look it up and get back to you!

    • Lisa says:

      I LOVE Ginger Ale, Cheryl! Thank you so much for this idea! Unfortunately, due to some site restoration, I lost the link you posted. Hopefully you’ll see this and post it again :)

  62. Pingback: 4-Ingredient Homemade Ricotta Cheese Recipe

Leave a Reply